Law, Economics, and Judicial Systems
Peer reviewed
Abstract
Abstract
ABSTRACT The value of lawyers to their clients is notoriously difficult to estimate because of endogeneity. We utilize modifications to the collateral source (CS) rule that require reducing trial awards by the amount of payments from first‐party insurance as an instrument for hiring a lawyer. The problem with our instrument is that modifications to the CS rule have a direct effect on recovery and, hence, violate the exclusion restriction required for a valid instrument. We develop a new identification and estimation method that uses CS rule changes as an invalid instrument and bounds the impact of lawyers. We find that our estimated impact's upper and lower bounds are lower than estimates that do not correct for endogeneity. Our estimates of the impact of lawyers on total payment are consistently negative, although not precise enough to claim statistical significance. The upper bound of the effect of hiring a lawyer on total payment received is negative after fees in our preferred specification. This suggests that even in the most optimistic scenario, lawyers appear to reduce total recovery.
Direct answer
What can I do from this paper page?
Use this page to scan "The Value of an Attorney: Collateral Source Rule Changes as an Invalid Instrument" quickly: start with the summary and abstract, then check the authors, source, topics, and related papers. From here, open Scollr to follow Law, Economics, and Judicial Systems research, save the paper, or map adjacent work.
Research areas
Follow related topics
Citation
BibTeX
@article{Helland2026Value,
title = {The Value of an Attorney: Collateral Source Rule Changes as an Invalid Instrument},
author = {Eric Helland and Jungmo Yoon},
journal = {Journal of Applied Econometrics},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.1002/jae.70094},
url = {https://doi.org/10.1002/jae.70094}
}FAQ
Using this paper in a discovery workflow
How do I find related work for this paper?
Use the related papers and topic links on this page as starting points. In Scollr, you can also open the paper and build a literature map around its references, citing papers, and related work.
How can I keep up with new Law, Economics, and Judicial Systems research papers?
Follow Law, Economics, and Judicial Systems research in Scollr. New papers from the topic flow into a personalized feed, and you can save useful studies to revisit later.
Can I cite this paper from this page?
This page includes a static BibTeX block for The Value of an Attorney: Collateral Source Rule Changes as an Invalid Instrument. Always verify the DOI, source, and publication details against the publisher record before submitting a manuscript.
Follow this research in Scollr
Follow the topics and authors behind this paper, save useful studies, and build a literature map when you are ready to go deeper.
Get the app